The Brokery480.999.9945

Central Scottsdale Compared

McCormick Ranch vs Gainey Ranch.

These are two Central Scottsdale planned communities, a mile apart and well apart at the single family median: the lakes-and-greenbelt master plan against the gated resort enclave built around a private club.

The numbers, side by side.

McCormick RanchGainey Ranch
Median sale$1,215,000$2,000,000
Price per square foot$561$618
Days to contract63 days62 days
Percent of list96%95%
Closed sales721

Single family, July 28, 2025 to July 27, 2026, ARMLS: closed Single Family Residence (detached) sales listed under the Gainey Ranch or McCormick Ranch subdivision name, from client reports Anne Sostman of The Brokery ran October 20, 2026. Sales listed only under a sub-neighborhood name are not included, so these counts run below community-wide totals.

McCormick Ranch

  • A master-planned community of lakes, 25 miles of bike paths, greenbelts and two public golf courses, with homes from patio villas to lakefront customs. Single family homes sold in a median 63 days (ARMLS, July 28, 2025 to July 27, 2026).
  • Choose it if: you want the classic greenbelt lifestyle with no gate and no mandatory club
  • Choose it if: value matters: $561 a foot for single family homes against $618 in Gainey Ranch
  • Choose it if: public-course golf and lake paths beat a private-club structure for you

Gainey Ranch

  • The gated evolution of the same idea: a guard-gated community wrapped around the private Gainey Ranch Golf Club and the Hyatt Regency resort, with estate sections and a $2,000,000 single family median over the twelve months to July 27, 2026 (ARMLS).
  • Choose it if: gates, club life and the resort polish are worth the premium to you
  • Choose it if: you want a guard-gated address on a private golf club
  • Choose it if: a gated market of about 21 single family sales a year suits what you are buying or selling

The honest split.

Single family homes in both sell at essentially the same pace, a median of about nine weeks. The single family median gap is structure, not distance: Gainey's gate, club and estate lots against McCormick's open greenbelt breadth.

Per square foot the gap narrows to $618 against $561, so much of Gainey's median premium is simply bigger homes: a median 3,114 square feet against 2,620. Buyers comparing a specific McCormick lakefront against a mid-Gainey patio home should run the per-foot math before assuming which one is the splurge.

Deciding between them?

I work both sides of this comparison and the honest answer usually depends on the specific house and street. The walkthrough is complimentary, in person, with a written net sheet if you are selling and a pocket-level comparable set either way.

Scottsdale Sold ReportCentral Scottsdale Seller's GuideNorth vs Central Scottsdale

Reviewed by Anne Sostman · The Brokery · Arizona License SA718853000 · September 2026