Scottsdale, Paradise Valley & Arcadia
What the Thirteen Months to September 2026 Actually Did.
Every figure on this page comes from ARMLS sold data for September 1, 2025 through September 30, 2026, measured against September 1, 2024 through September 30, 2025, for single-family detached homes. September 2025 falls in both periods. No estimates, no projections. Where a number is derived rather than reported, it says so.
Anne Sostman
The Headline
Three Markets. Three Different Stories.
All ten Scottsdale zip codes closed more single-family homes from September 2025 to September 2026 than a year earlier, from 6% more in 85259 to 49% more in 85257. The average sale price rose in nine of the ten, from 1% in 85262 to 18% in 85250, and held flat in 85257. Sale-to-list stayed at 96 to 97% in every zip that reported it, and days on market rose in all ten. That is a market absorbing more homes at steady prices without giving up negotiating position, while taking longer to do it.
Anne Sostman @ The Brokery, who wrote this guide, sums it up: “Averages across a city hide the story. Paradise Valley and South Scottsdale both had a strong year, but for completely opposite reasons, one on price, one on volume. Knowing which one describes your street is the difference between pricing well and guessing.”
Paradise Valley tells a different story: 359 homes sold, up 11% from 324, but the average sale price jumped 21% to $5,599,388 and volume rose 34%. A price increase nearly twice the gain in units means the mix moved upmarket, not that every home appreciated by that much. Sale-to-list eased from 96% to 95%, and days on market fell from 99 to 95, while they rose in all ten Scottsdale zips and in Arcadia.
Section 01, Arcadia
Arcadia Grew on Both Counts.
Arcadia grew on both counts. 468 single-family homes sold against 389 a year earlier, a 20% increase, at an average of $2,100,625, up 6%. Total sales volume rose 28%.
Both figures moving together is what makes it notable. Rising volume alone can mean a market clearing inventory at soft prices; rising price alone can mean a handful of large sales distorting the average. Arcadia did both at once, while holding 96% of list at 81 days on market, up from 75. For sellers, that is evidence of genuine demand depth in the corridor.
Section 02 By Area
Scottsdale Is Not One Market. Here Is the Proof.
Broken out by zip code, the spread between Scottsdale's submarkets is wider than the citywide average suggests, from an average sale price of $690,913 in 85257 to $2,245,312 in 85255, over the same thirteen months.
Section 03 What It Means
Reading These Numbers as a Seller.
**South Scottsdale's two zips moved in different ways, and both are healthy.** 85257 sold 49% more homes at an unchanged average: that is an affordability-driven market widening its buyer pool, not a market weakening. 85250, beside Old Town, sold 13% more homes at an 18% higher average. A seller in either area who reads only the citywide number will price wrong.
**Days on market lengthened almost everywhere.** They rose in all ten Scottsdale zips, from 63 to 64 days in McCormick Ranch up to 110 to 131 in Troon and Desert Mountain, and in Arcadia from 75 to 81. Paradise Valley was the exception, down from 99 to 95. Plan your timeline around the longer clock.
**Sale-to-list is the number to watch.** Scottsdale zips held 96 to 97%, Arcadia 96%, Paradise Valley slipped to 95%. Those are strong ratios, but they describe correctly priced homes. A property that launches above the market does not get the average; it gets a reduction and a longer clock.
Section 04, Method
Where These Numbers Come From.
Stated plainly, so you can judge the data yourself.
Common Questions
Questions Buyers and Owners Ask Most.
Work With Anne
Want These Numbers for Your Street?
Zip-code data is the finest resolution published. Your pocket, your price band, and your product type behave differently, and that analysis is the one that matters before you list.
Explore More
Related Resources.
Market UpdateMonthly Market ReportsThe ongoing read on Scottsdale, Paradise Valley, and Arcadia. | Seller's GuideWhat It Costs to Sell a HomeEvery cost category, and how to calculate your net proceeds. | Seller's GuideWhat Is My Home Worth?How to get an honest valuation built on real comparables. |
