The Brokery480.999.9945
Old Town Scottsdale Homes For Sale
Old Town Scottsdale Real Estate
Reviewed by Anne Sostman | The Brokery | Arizona License SA718853000 | September 2026

Old Town Scottsdale
Homes for Sale.

Old Town Scottsdale · 85251 · Condos · Lofts · Single Family · Anne Sostman, The Brokery

Old Town is a walkable urban district in Scottsdale: galleries, James Beard dining, Fashion Square, the Scottsdale Waterfront, and a residential market that ranges from lock-and-leave condos to single family estates on the surrounding streets. Ask me for the homes that match your criteria, including off-market properties that never reach the public portals.

“Old Town buyers are paying for a life they can step into immediately. The moment a property asks them to wait, imagine, or compromise, you have lost the premium and often the buyer. This is a market that rewards preparation from both sides of the transaction.”
Anne Sostman
$407K / $874K
85251 condo and townhome / single family medians, July 2025 to July 2026 (ARMLS)
$341/sqft
Median price per sq ft, 85251 condos and townhomes, Jul 2025 to Jul 2026
75-90
Walk Score range in the Old Town core
14-21
Days well-priced properties generate offers in peak season

Old Town Scottsdale Specialist

Condos · Lofts · Single Family

Private Client Network

Off-Market Access

Published by Anne Sostman

Know the Market

Three Ways to Live in Old Town.

Old Town is not one market. A luxury loft on Scottsdale Road, a townhome near the Waterfront, and a mid-century ranch two blocks south of Indian School serve entirely different lives, appreciate on different trajectories, and compete against different resale inventory. Knowing which property type matches your life is the first decision that matters.

Anne Sostman @ The Brokery, who wrote this page, tells her clients: “Old Town buyers are paying for a life they can step into immediately. The moment a property asks them to wait, imagine, or compromise, you have lost the premium and often the buyer. This is a market that rewards preparation from both sides of the transaction.”

Condos and lofts dominate the inventory. Single family homes are scarcer and sell faster. Townhomes offer the middle ground. Start with the property type, then browse the listings that apply.

Old Town Neighborhood Guide

Condos & Luxury Lofts
The most common inventory type. Lock-and-leave convenience, walkability to everything, and the full urban lifestyle. Attached homes in 85251 sold at a $407K median (ARMLS, July 2025 to July 2026). Anne Sostman flags HOA quality as an often overlooked risk factor: review the reserve study before you commit.
Single Family Homes
Residential streets surrounding Old Town’s core. Yard space, privacy, and long-term appreciation. Single family homes in 85251 sold at a $874K median (ARMLS, July 2025 to July 2026). These move fast with less negotiating room.
Townhomes
The middle ground between condo convenience and single family space. Small private outdoor area, attached living, and proximity to the walkable core. The Old Town address without full condo density.

Surrounding Communities

Old Town Adjacent Neighborhoods.

The residential communities that share Old Town’s walkability, dining access, and cultural proximity. Each has its own character and price dynamics.

Single Family · Walkable
Park Scottsdale
Walking distance to Old Town’s core. Mid-century ranches to modern rebuilds. Ongoing renovation activity.

Guide →

Single Family · Character
Scottsdale Estates
Homes built in the 1950s and 1960s. Larger lots, mid-century character, established streets, and Old Town proximity.

Guide →

Condos & Lofts
Old Town Luxury Lofts
Urban lifestyle in the walkable core. Lock-and-leave condos and luxury lofts from studios to penthouses.

Guide →

Single Family · 85251
South of Indian School
Ranch homes from the 1950s alongside new builds and renovations, close to Old Town.

Guide →

Mid-Century · Greenbelt
Sands East & Sands North
Mid-century modern oasis adjacent to the Greenbelt. Strong renovation activity and design-forward remodels.

Guide →

Townhomes · Greenbelt
Continental Villas
Established townhome community with Greenbelt access and Old Town proximity.

Guide →

Take the Next Step

Looking for the Right Old Town Property?
Condos, lofts, or single family: the property type is the first decision.

Some Old Town properties, particularly single family homes and premium lofts, trade through private channels. Request access to current off-market inventory.

Representing buyers and sellers across Old Town & South Scottsdale communities  ·  480.999.9945

What Sets Old Town Apart

Why Buyers Pay a Premium for Old Town.

Walkability
A Walkable District
In Old Town you can walk to dinner, to galleries, to Fashion Square, to the Waterfront, and back home. That walkability carries a measurable price premium of $50 to $100+ per square foot over comparable properties just a few blocks outside the walkable core.
Culture
Galleries, Dining and Museums
Over 100 galleries, the Scottsdale ArtWalk running every Thursday since 1975, James Beard-recognized restaurants, SMoCA, Western Spirit: Scottsdale’s Museum of the West, and a dining scene that attracts national recognition. Old Town residents live inside this. It is not a drive away, it is their neighborhood.
Investment
Constrained Supply, Consistent Demand
Old Town’s geographic footprint is fixed. The land is built out. New inventory comes from redevelopment, not expansion. That supply constraint, combined with consistent demand, has supported appreciation. Properties with strong fundamentals in the walkable core hold value through market cycles.
Rental Demand
Strong Short-Term and Long-Term Rental Performance
Old Town has both seasonal and event-driven short-term rental demand. The Waste Management Open, Barrett-Jackson, Scottsdale Arabian Horse Show, and spring training all drive occupancy. Long-term rental demand is supported by the walkable lifestyle. Verify rental restrictions in your specific HOA before purchasing for rental purposes.

Resources

Old Town Buyer and Seller Guides.

For Buyers
Old Town Buyer’s Guide
Property types, pricing tiers, HOA due diligence, what drives value, offer strategy, and the specific mistakes buyers make in Old Town. 10 sections from search to close.

Read Guide →

For Sellers
Old Town Seller’s Guide
How to position an Old Town property for the outcome it deserves. Buyer psychology, pricing strategy, preparation standards, and negotiation dynamics.

Read Guide →

Neighborhood
Old Town Neighborhood Guide
Old Town Scottsdale’s culture, dining, architecture, lifestyle, and market dynamics.

Read Guide →

Frequently Asked Questions

Old Town Scottsdale Real Estate FAQ.

What is the average home price?
In 85251, condos and townhomes sold at a $407K median and single family homes at a $874K median (ARMLS, July 2025 to July 2026). Condos and townhomes in 85251 sold at a $341 median price per square foot from July 2025 to July 2026 (ARMLS); luxury buildings trade well above it. Single family homes on surrounding streets are priced on condition and lot size.
Is Old Town walkable?
Yes. Residents walk to dining, galleries, Fashion Square, the Waterfront, and nightlife. Walk Score rates the core between 75 and 90.
Should I buy a condo or a house?
Condos for lock-and-leave convenience and walkability. Single family for yard space, privacy, and stronger long-term appreciation. The choice depends on your lifestyle priority and whether you intend to use the property seasonally or full-time.
Are there off-market homes?
Yes. Some Old Town properties trade through private channels before reaching the MLS, particularly single family homes and premium lofts. The Private Client Network provides access.
How competitive is the market?
Well-priced properties generate multiple offers within 14 to 21 days during peak season. Being pre-approved and prepared to move quickly is essential.
What types of homes are available?
Condos and luxury lofts (most common), townhomes, single family homes on surrounding residential streets, and new construction. Each type has different HOA, maintenance, and resale dynamics.

Common Questions

Questions Sellers Ask Most.

What is the average home price in Old Town Scottsdale?
In 85251, which takes in Old Town Scottsdale, condos and townhomes sold at a $407K median and single family homes at a $874K median from July 2025 to July 2026 (ARMLS); renovated single family homes and premium luxury lofts sit at the top of the range. Condos and townhomes in 85251 sold at a $341 median price per square foot from July 2025 to July 2026 (ARMLS); luxury buildings trade well above it. Single family homes on surrounding residential streets are priced on condition and lot size.
Is Old Town Scottsdale walkable?
Yes. Residents walk to dining, galleries, shopping, nightlife, the Scottsdale Waterfront, and Scottsdale Fashion Square. Walk Score rates the core between 75 and 90 depending on exact location. Anne Sostman of The Brokery walks buyers through this decision with pocket data rather than portal averages.
What types of homes are available in Old Town Scottsdale?
Old Town offers condos and luxury lofts (the most common inventory type), townhomes, single family homes on traditional lots in surrounding residential streets, and new construction luxury residences. Each property type carries different HOA, maintenance, and resale considerations. Working with Anne Sostman, this question gets answered with numbers for the specific homes you are weighing.
Are there off-market homes for sale in Old Town Scottsdale?
Yes. Some Old Town properties, particularly single family homes and premium lofts, trade through private channels before reaching the MLS. The Private Client Network provides access to these off-market opportunities for qualified buyers.
Should I buy a condo or a house in Old Town Scottsdale?
Condos offer lock-and-leave convenience, lower maintenance, and proximity to the walkable core. Single family homes offer yard space, privacy, and typically stronger long-term appreciation. The choice depends on how you intend to use the property and whether lifestyle access or residential space is your priority.
How competitive is the Old Town Scottsdale market?
Well-priced, well-presented properties generate multiple offers within 14 to 21 days during peak season. Being pre-approved and prepared to move quickly is essential. Working with Anne Sostman, this question gets answered with numbers for the specific homes you are weighing.

Matching Listings

Get the Homes That Fit.

Tell me your criteria, price, size, must-haves, and I’ll send matching homes, including off-market opportunities you won’t find on the public portals.

Request Matching Listings

Work With Anne

Looking for Something Specific in Old Town?

Public listing sites show only what is publicly available. For off-market properties, building-specific condo searches, or a private conversation about which part of Old Town matches your lifestyle, a consultation is the right first step.

Schedule directly below

Or call directly

480.999.9945