September 2026
Market
Update.
September moved Scottsdale's sales up the price ladder: more closings above one million, with fewer homes for sale there, and fewer below it. Paradise Valley sold faster. Arcadia's median fell on the mix of homes that sold. The analysis is Anne Sostman's, built from the ARMLS record for Scottsdale, Paradise Valley and Arcadia.
Anne Sostman
September 2026 ARMLS Data
Scottsdale, Arcadia & Paradise Valley
All Dwelling Types
Closed, Pending, Active and New
City, Town and ZIP Level, Not Metro Averages
Market Overview
More Sales Above a Million.
Fewer Homes for Sale There.
Per ARMLS data for September 2026 analyzed by Anne Sostman of The Brokery, Scottsdale closed 483 sales across all residential dwelling types, up 1.9% year over year, at a median of $950,000, up 8.8%, and an average of $1,324,692, up 7.0%. That is $639.8M in closed volume.* Paradise Valley closed 25, down 7.4%, at a median of $3,325,000, up 7.3%. Arcadia (85018) closed 37, up 2.8%, at a median of $750,000, down 25.2%.
The change is inside the price bands. Scottsdale closings at $1M and above rose from 202 to 229, and above $2M from 63 to 80. In the same range, active listings fell to 971 from 1,083. More buyers closed at the top while fewer homes were for sale there. Below $1M it went the other way: closings fell from 272 to 254 while active listings rose to 1,205 from 1,162.
Contracts need a second look. The first count of September contracts in Scottsdale was 357 against 471 a year earlier, down 24.2%. Late entries keep posting for weeks, and by Anne Sostman's November 9 export the same month counted 414. In Arcadia the first count of 38 became 50, above last September's 48. The first count of any month's contracts understates demand.
Two Markets, Two Readings
Scottsdale vs. Paradise Valley.
| Scottsdale
The Top Grew.
The Middle Waited. Scottsdale closed 483 residential sales in September, up 1.9% year over year, at a median of $950,000, up 8.8%. New listings rose to 937, up 8.3%, and active listings stood at 2,176, down 3.1%, for 3.91 months of supply against 4.37 a year ago. Median days on market were 70 against 71, and sellers collected 97% of list price. Year to date: 5,115 closings, up 5.7%, at a median of $952,500, up 7.4%.
|
Paradise Valley
Fewer Sales.
Faster Sales. Paradise Valley closed 25 sales against 27 a year earlier, at a median of $3,325,000, up 7.3%. Of those, 14 were above $3M, against 16. Homes sold faster: median days on market fell to 30 from 66. The average of $3,466,260, down 12.8%, moves on a handful of estates at this transaction count and should be read gently. Active listings were 203, down 2.4%, at 5.7 months of supply. Year to date Paradise Valley has closed 327 sales against 319, at a median of $3,991,750, up 10.9%.
|
Arcadia, 85018
The Median Fell.
Values Did Not.
Arcadia's September median of $750,000 is down 25.2% from last September's $1,002,500. The cause is what sold. Arcadia closed 15 homes at $1M or more against 18 a year earlier, and 22 below it against 18. With more of the month's sales below $1M, the midpoint fell far more than values did.
The year to date is the number to hold on to: 479 closings, up 16.5%, at a median of $1,175,000, up 10.8%. September sellers collected 95.7% of list price, with median days on market at 72 against 47 last September.
Supply was steady. New listings were 105, down 2.8%, and active listings 268, up 2.3%, at 5.15 months of supply.
What This Means
For Sellers and Buyers.
| If You Are Selling
Your strategy depends on your price band. At $1M and above, Scottsdale closings rose to 229 from 202 while active listings there fell to 971 from 1,083; a prepared listing in that range has fewer homes to compete with. Below $1M, active listings rose to 1,205 from 1,162 while closings fell, so the asking price has to be right on the first day. Homes priced from closed comparables still collected 97% of list. In Arcadia, the year to date median, up 10.8%, is the honest guide to value, not September's median.
|
If You Are Buying
Below $1M in Scottsdale, September gave buyers more to choose from, 1,205 active listings against 1,162 a year ago, with fewer closings competing for them. Above $1M, fewer homes were for sale and more of them closed, so a well priced home there will not wait for a second look. In Paradise Valley, median days on market fell to 30: the homes that were priced right sold quickly.
|
Looking Ahead
What to Watch
in October.
First, the top of the market. Scottsdale closings at $1M and above were up 13.4% in September with active listings in that range down 10.3%. If that continues into the season, sellers there hold the stronger hand.
Second, the middle. Scottsdale active listings under $1M were up 3.7% while closings were down 6.6%. Watch whether new buyers arrive with the season to absorb them.
Third, Arcadia's mix. September's median of $750K came from a month weighted below $1M. When the mix returns to normal, expect the monthly median to move back toward the year to date figure of $1.18M.
Common Questions
Questions Sellers Ask Most.
Your Position
Ready to Talk About Your Position?
A market median tells you what happened across hundreds of homes. It does not tell you what yours is worth, or which side of the million dollar line your street is on. Send me the address and I will give you a straight read, at no cost and with no obligation to list with me.
Keep Reading
Other Market Updates.
Next MonthOctober 2026 Market ReportClosings, contracts and prices for Scottsdale, Arcadia and Paradise Valley, with September’s contract recount. | Last MonthAugust 2026 Market ReportClosings, prices and supply for Scottsdale, Arcadia and Paradise Valley in August. | Your HomeWhat’s Your Home Worth?Turn market data into a number for your specific property: a real valuation from inside these neighborhoods, not an algorithm’s guess. |
*Closed volume is the ARMLS sold sale volume for the month. Paradise Valley’s average sale price is sensitive to composition given its low monthly transaction count. Contract (pending) counts rise as late entries post; the recounts shown are from Market Summary exports downloaded November 9, 2026. All other figures are ARMLS residential data for September 2026, all dwelling types, compared with September 2025, from Market Summary exports downloaded October 20, 2026; Paradise Valley is the Town of Paradise Valley. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Data: ARMLS. Analysis: Anne Sostman, The Brokery, Arizona license SA718853000.
