What Questions Should I Ask a Realtor
Before Listing My Home?
Ask every realtor the same ten questions before you list: What have you sold in my neighborhood and price band in the last two years? Which closed sales support your price, and which did you leave out? What is the expected sale price, not just the list price? What is the written marketing plan for my home, including photography, video, a property page, paid social and a pre-market launch? How will buyers using Google and AI search tools find my listing? Who personally attends the inspection, appraisal and final walkthrough? What will I net, in writing? What does your fee include? How do I cancel the listing agreement? May I speak with two recent sellers? Anne Sostman of Anne Sostman @ The Brokery, a Scottsdale, Paradise Valley and Arcadia listing agent, explains below why each question matters and what a real answer sounds like.
Anne Sostman
How to Use This
Ask Every Agent. Including This One.
A listing presentation is a sales meeting. That is not a criticism. It is what it is. Your job is to convert it into an interview by asking questions with checkable answers, then comparing responses across three agents rather than being persuaded by one.
Anne Sostman @ The Brokery, who wrote this guide, tells her clients: “Interview at least three. Ask all of them the same questions. The differences will be obvious, and they will not be the differences the brochures emphasize.”
Watch for two things beyond the content. Whether the agent answers directly or redirects to marketing material, and whether they are willing to tell you something you might not want to hear. An agent who agrees with every price you suggest is not helping you.
Section 01, Results
Questions About Their Actual Record.
How many homes have you sold in my specific area and price band in the last two years? Area means your neighborhood or zip, not the metro. What is your list-to-sale ratio, and how does it compare to the local average? The comparison matters more than the number. What is your average days on market versus the local median? How many of your listings did not sell, and what happened? Every experienced agent has some. An agent who claims none is either new or not being straight with you. May I speak with two recent sellers whose homes were similar to mine?
Section 02, Pricing
Questions About How They Price.
This is the category most sellers skip because the number feels like the whole answer. It is not. The method behind the number is what you are hiring, because the method is what adjusts correctly when the market moves.
Scottsdale closings from July 2025 to July 2026 (ARMLS) show what the method is worth: homes priced right kept 98 percent of original asking, while homes that had to cut sat a median 102 days on market. The agent who prices from evidence and the agent who prices to win the meeting produce very different outcomes from the same house.
Section 03, Marketing and Reach
Questions About the Marketing Plan.
Who specifically is the buyer for this home, and how will you reach them? A serious answer starts from what the home offers and names specific channels. What happens beyond the MLS and the portals? Everyone lists on the MLS; that is not marketing. Can you sell it off-market if I want discretion, and what does that cost me in price? Who pays for photography, staging consultation, and marketing, and what happens to that if the home does not sell? Will you hold open houses, and do you believe they sell homes or generate buyer leads? The honest answer to the last one is usually the latter, and an agent who says so is being straight with you.
Section 04, The New Questions
The Questions Most Sellers Do Not Know to Ask Yet.
A growing share of buyers ask AI assistants to shortlist homes before they ever open a portal. The machine reads every listing it can parse and hands its favorites to a person. Listings it cannot read never make the list, which makes the next three questions the newest part of any serious interview.
Anne Sostman publishes her answers to all three. Every campaign Anne Sostman runs meets an AI-ready standard before launch and is reviewed, curated, and executed by her personally, with a career in marketing behind the judgment. Anne Sostman’s most recent documented campaign produced an offer before the home was officially on the market and closed at 99 percent of asking per the ARMLS record. The full method is at luxury home marketing, and the campaign is in the Glenrosa case study.
Section 05, Working Together
Questions About the Relationship.
Will you personally handle my listing, or does it transfer to a team member after signing? Ask specifically who attends showings, who negotiates, and who you call at nine at night. How often will I hear from you, and through what channel, including weeks when nothing happens? Silence during slow periods is the most common complaint sellers have. How many listings are you carrying right now? There is no correct number, but the answer tells you about attention. How do you handle it when we disagree about price?
Section 06, The Contract
Questions to Ask Before You Sign.
The last category is the contract itself, and the rule here is absolute: get every one of these answers in writing, not in conversation. These four terms are the ones sellers most often discover after signing, and every one of them is negotiable before.
Common Questions
What Sellers Ask About Interviewing Agents.
Work With Anne
Bring These to Me Too.
I would rather you interview three agents with this list than hire me without it. If another agent's answers are stronger, you should know that before you sign.
Explore More
Related Resources.
The MethodHow a Luxury Home Actually Gets MarketedThe five layers of a real campaign, and the AI-ready standard, from a marketer who became an agent. | Seller's GuideWhat It Costs to Sell a HomeEvery cost category, and how to calculate your net proceeds. | Seller's GuideWhat Happens If My House Doesn't Sell?Why listings stall, and how to relaunch properly. |
