The Scottsdale Relocation Index
Q1 2026.
The inaugural issue of The Scottsdale Relocation Index. A quarterly publication anchored in IRS migration data, Tax Foundation analysis, Cromford Report luxury segment data, and Arizona Regional MLS closings. Published with full citations, methodology disclosure, and Anne Sostman’s reading of the data, labeled as analysis. The data tells one story. What it means for buyers, sellers, and the trajectory of the Scottsdale luxury market is the story this Index is built to tell.
Anne Sostman
IRS Migration Data
Tax Foundation Analysis
Cromford Report
Arizona Regional MLS
Q1 2026 Closings
Executive Summary
Q1 2026 in Three Sentences,
Then the Detail.
One. The IRS migration data for returns filed in 2022 and 2023 (tax years 2021 and 2022, the most recent available) confirm that California, New York, Illinois, New Jersey, and Massachusetts continue to lose net tax filers to lower tax states, with Arizona ranking sixth nationally for net inbound migration at a gain of 17,316 filers. Maricopa County alone netted 13,793 inbound migrants from other states.
Two. The Phoenix metro luxury segment in Q1 2026 is outperforming the broader market by a wide margin. Per the Cromford Report, sales over $3M are up 26 percent year over year, and 26 ultra luxury closings over $10M occurred in Q1 alone, already 81 percent of the full year 2025 record before the quarter closed.
Three. The figures in this issue do not show which Scottsdale, Paradise Valley, or Arcadia submarkets relocation purchases went to. Anne’s Analysis below is Anne Sostman’s reading of what the figures above may mean for buyers and sellers.
Section One: Migration Data
The IRS Migration Data,
State by State.
The IRS Statistics of Income migration files track domestic migration based on year over year address changes on individual income tax returns. The most recent data available covers returns filed in 2022 and 2023, which are tax years 2021 and 2022. Newer IRS migration data had not been released when this issue was published.
| State | Net Filer Change 2022 to 2023 | Top State Income Tax Rate | Direction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arizona | +17,316 | 2.5% flat | Net inbound |
| Texas | +56,473 | No state income tax | Net inbound |
| Florida | +55,349 | No state income tax | Net inbound |
| California | −100,397 | 13.3% top rate | Net outbound |
| New York | −71,987 | 10.9% state plus 3.876% NYC | Net outbound |
| Illinois | −28,609 | 4.95% flat | Net outbound |
| Massachusetts | −15,378 | 5% plus 4% surtax above $1M | Net outbound |
| Washington | Mixed (gains in returns, smaller in individuals) | 7% to 9.9% on long-term capital gains above $278,000 (2025) | Mixed |
| Colorado | +11,341 | 4.40% flat | Net inbound |
Source: Tax Foundation analysis of IRS Statistics of Income migration data, returns filed in 2022 and 2023 (tax years 2021 and 2022). Net change in income tax filers from interstate migration. Top state income tax rates current for tax year 2025. The IRS withholds county to county data when fewer than 20 filers move between any two counties, so some flows are necessarily aggregated. Date pulled May 2026.
Section Two: County Level Flows
Where Maricopa County’s New Residents
Are Coming From.
Maricopa County (Phoenix metro, including Scottsdale and Paradise Valley) absorbed 13,793 net migrants from other states in the IRS data for returns filed in 2022 and 2023 (tax years 2021 and 2022), the highest of any Arizona county. Per the IRS data, the top originating counties tell a clear story about where the relocation pressure is coming from.
| Originating County | Migrants to Arizona | Major City |
|---|---|---|
| Los Angeles County, CA | 9,350 | Los Angeles |
| San Diego County, CA | 7,283 | San Diego |
| Riverside County, CA | 5,406 | Riverside, Palm Springs |
Source: IRS Statistics of Income migration data, county to county flows, returns filed in 2022 and 2023 (tax years 2021 and 2022). Migrants are individuals, summed across the Arizona counties the IRS publishes for each California county. Note: County level data is filtered by the IRS to maintain confidentiality where fewer than 20 filers move between specific counties. The figures shown represent the top three California county sources to Arizona; smaller flows from Cook County (Chicago), King County (Seattle), and other major metros also contribute meaningfully but are not always disclosed at the county to county level. The IRS releases new county to county data once a year.
The three California counties shown sent 22,039 migrants to Arizona in these IRS files: 9,350 from Los Angeles County, 7,283 from San Diego County, and 5,406 from Riverside County.
Section Three: AGI Flows
The AGI Migration Story
Is the Real Story.
The headline migration numbers tell you how many people are moving. The AGI (Adjusted Gross Income) flow data tells you how much income moves with them. For the luxury relocation segment that this Index tracks, AGI flows are the more important indicator.
Per Tax Foundation analysis of the most recent IRS data, among taxpayers with $200,000 or more in AGI, the most attractive destination states were Florida, Texas, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Arizona. Per the same analysis, the states losing the most taxpayers in that AGI group were California, New York, Illinois, Massachusetts, and New Jersey.
In a single year, California lost 24,670 taxpayers with $200,000 plus AGI, reducing the state’s combined AGI base by approximately $16.1 billion. The IRS releases this data once a year.
Section Four: Q1 2026 Luxury Segment
The Luxury Market Is Outperforming
By a Wide Margin.
The Cromford Report Q1 2026 analysis of Phoenix metro housing data confirms a sharp divergence between the luxury segment and the broader market.
| Segment | Q1 2026 Performance | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Phoenix Metro median sale | $925,000 (Scottsdale) | Down 8.6% YoY citywide Scottsdale aggregate. The headline number is misleading without the band breakdown. |
| Mortgage rate environment | ~6.0% to 6.4% | Freddie Mac 30-year average during Q1 2026, rising in late March; 7.40% by October 15, 2026. Cash buyers are insulated from rate volatility. |
| Cromford Demand Index | 13% below normal | Improving from 16% below normal a month earlier. Recovery trajectory is consistent with relocation flow patterns. |
Source: Cromford Report, Q1 2026 commentary by Tina Tamboer, Senior Housing Analyst. Data from the Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service. The Cromford Report’s data is licensed from ARMLS.
Section Five: Anne’s Analysis
What the Q1 2026 Data
Actually Means.
The data sections above are facts. The analysis below is Anne Sostman’s reading of that data. It is opinion, labeled as such so the reader can separate evidence from interpretation, and it adds no counts from her own transactions.
The headline migration story is misleading without the AGI overlay.
Arizona ranks sixth nationally for net inbound tax filer migration. That sounds modest. But Arizona ranks fifth nationally for inbound migration of taxpayers with $200,000 plus AGI. Filers with $200,000 plus AGI are overrepresented in Arizona’s inbound flow, which is exactly why the luxury segment of the Phoenix metro market is materially outperforming the broader market. The migration numbers and the luxury sales numbers are not two separate stories. They are the same story, told from two different angles.
The luxury increase is not a peak. It is a trend line.
The Cromford Report’s Q1 2026 commentary frames the luxury segment as having an “extraordinary season.” That language understates the structural nature of what is happening. Moves away from California’s 13.3 percent income tax, New York’s 14.8 percent combined rate, and Massachusetts’s new $1M surtax are not going to reverse course in 2027. Luxury demand in Scottsdale and Paradise Valley is being driven by a tax structure decision that is, for most relocators, permanent.
The Massachusetts surtax and the state’s net filer loss.
In 2022, Massachusetts passed a 4 percent surtax on individual income above $1M, effective 2023. The Massachusetts Department of Revenue reported collecting nearly $3B from the surtax in fiscal 2025. The IRS data shows Massachusetts losing 15,378 net tax filers in 2022 to 2023. That figure covers the whole state; the data in this issue does not show how many of those filers moved to Arizona.
Three kinds of setting within the market.
Scottsdale, Paradise Valley, and Arcadia offer three kinds of setting: master-planned, guard-gated communities such as DC Ranch and Silverleaf; walkable urban or central residential areas such as Old Town Scottsdale and Arcadia; and larger lots in Paradise Valley and the Camelback Country Club corridor. This is Anne Sostman’s reading of the submarkets, not a count of transactions; the data in this issue does not break out closings by submarket.
What the Q2 2026 issue covers.
The Q2 2026 issue, published October 2026, reports IRS migration data, U.S. Census Bureau population and housing estimates, and 2026 state income tax rates from the Tax Foundation, each with its source and period. It also reports ARMLS closings from April 1 to June 30, 2026 for Scottsdale, Paradise Valley, and Arcadia ZIP codes.
Section Six: Methodology
How Each Number
Was Sourced.
The defensibility of the Index depends on every reader being able to verify the numbers themselves. Every data point above is sourced. Every methodology decision is documented. Every limitation is named. This section is the audit trail.
IRS migration data: Statistics of Income (SOI) Tax Stats, U.S. Population Migration Data. Annual study based on year over year address changes on Form 1040 returns. Most recent data covers returns filed in 2022 and 2023 (tax years 2021 and 2022), released by the IRS in March 2026. State to state and county to county flows. The IRS suppresses county to county flows where fewer than 20 filers moved between any two counties. Limitation: late filers are excluded from the data. Limitation: the data lags 18 to 24 months from the actual move year.
Tax Foundation analysis: Independent tax policy organization based in Washington DC. Their state migration trends analysis aggregates the IRS SOI data with state tax structure context. Citation pulled from Tax Foundation’s “State Migration Trends” report, updated annually. The Index relies on Tax Foundation analysis for the AGI breakdown and the state by state net migration figures.
Cromford Report: Phoenix metro housing data, licensed from the Arizona Regional MLS. Daily updates with quarterly summaries published by Tina Tamboer, Senior Housing Analyst. The Cromford Report’s Q1 2026 commentary is the source for the luxury segment performance figures (sales over $3M, sales over $10M, mortgage rate environment, Cromford Demand Index).
Anne’s Analysis: Anne Sostman’s reading of the data in this issue. It is interpretive rather than statistical, is labeled as analysis throughout, and adds no counts from her own transactions.
Frequently Asked
About
The Index.
|
What is The Scottsdale Relocation Index?
A quarterly report by Anne Sostman of The Brokery on migration into Scottsdale, Paradise Valley, and Arcadia. The Index is built from public data: IRS Statistics of Income migration data, U.S. Census Bureau population estimates, and Tax Foundation state tax data, plus Arizona Regional MLS closings when that quarter’s export is available. This Q1 2026 issue draws on IRS and Tax Foundation data and on the Cromford Report’s Q1 2026 commentary.
How many people are relocating to Arizona from California?
Per the most recent IRS migration data (returns filed in 2022 and 2023, tax years 2021 and 2022), Los Angeles County alone contributed 9,350 migrants to Arizona, San Diego County 7,283, and Riverside County 5,406. Maricopa County (Phoenix metro, including Scottsdale) received 13,793 net migrants from other states, the highest of any Arizona county in the same IRS data. California lost 100,397 net tax filers in the same period.
Where is the Scottsdale luxury market in Q1 2026?
Per the Cromford Report Q1 2026 analysis, sales over $3M in the Greater Phoenix area were up 26 percent year over year through Q1 2026, including 26 ultra luxury closings over $10M. The luxury segment is materially outperforming the broader market, with the Cromford Report noting Scottsdale and Paradise Valley as the primary drivers of luxury volume in the metro.
|
Why are people relocating to Arizona from higher-tax states?
Arizona offers a flat 2.5 percent state income tax versus California’s 13.3 percent top rate or New York’s 14.8 percent combined rate. No estate tax, no inheritance tax, and a 25 percent subtraction on qualifying long term capital gains. Property tax rates roughly half of comparable luxury markets in the Northeast or West Coast. Beyond tax, Arizona offers about 296 clear or partly cloudy days a year at Phoenix Sky Harbor (per NOAA), direct flights from Sky Harbor to every major U.S. business hub, and luxury housing inventory at a fraction of comparable coastal pricing.
How often is The Index published?
Quarterly. Each issue is named for a calendar quarter and is published after that quarter, once that quarter’s data is available. Q1 2026 Issue (covering January through March 2026) published May 2026. Q2 2026 Issue (covering April through June 2026) published October 2026. Later issues are published quarterly as data allows.
Can I cite the Index in my own publication?
Yes. The Index is published with the expectation that journalists, industry analysts, tax professionals, and other agents may reference its findings. Citation format suggested: “The Scottsdale Relocation Index, Q1 2026 Issue, by Anne Sostman. Available at the link below.” For press inquiries or to request the underlying data behind any figure cited, contact Anne directly at 480.999.9945.
|
Common Questions
Questions Sellers Ask Most.
For Buyers and Sellers Acting on This Data
The Index Tells You What is Happening.
The Conversation Tells You What to Do About It.
A 30 minute private consultation about your specific situation. If you are a buyer evaluating a relocation, the Index is the starting point, what you do with it depends on your timeline, your origin city, your tax planning, and your target submarket. If you are a seller, the Q1 luxury segment data has direct implications for pricing strategy and timing. The Index is the data. The conversation is how it gets applied.
Schedule directly below
Or call directly
Index Archive
Issues of
the Index.
|
This Issue
Q1 2026 Inaugural Issue
Published May 2026. IRS migration data, Tax Foundation analysis, and Cromford Report figures for Q1 2026, with methodology and Anne’s Analysis.
|
Current Issue
Q2 2026 Issue
Published October 2026. IRS migration data, Census Bureau Vintage 2025 estimates, and 2026 state income tax rates, each with its source and period.
|
Index Hub
All Issues + Methodology
The Index hub page contains all published issues, the standing methodology, and citation guidance for journalists and industry analysts referencing the data.
|
Reviewed by Anne Sostman · The Brokery · Arizona License SA718853000 · September 2026
