The Brokery480.999.9945

Arcadia, Phoenix

Arcadia Proper Homes for Sale

Arcadia Proper is the original Arcadia. Estate sized lots from half acre to 1+ acre, mature citrus trees, midcentury to contemporary architecture, and a $3.63M single family median (ARMLS, July 2025 to July 2026).

Homes for Sale

Looking for a home in Arcadia Proper?

Tell me your criteria and I’ll send what is actually available in Arcadia Proper, including homes that trade privately and never reach the public portals.

Arcadia Proper Market Snapshot

Verified · ARMLS · July 2025 to July 2026
$3.1M
Median sale price
79
Sales, July 2025 to July 2026
$819
Median price per sq ft
76
Median days on market
95%
Of list price
21
Active listings
Source: ARMLS closed sales matched to Arcadia Proper, July 2025 to July 2026. Medians are suppressed below 6 sales. A starting point for pricing, not a valuation of a specific home. Reviewed by Anne Sostman, The Brokery, Arizona License SA718853000,September 2026.

Arcadia Proper Area (85018) Market Snapshot

Verified · All home types · Jul 1, 2025 to Jul 29, 2026
$1,629,871
Average sale price
+9% year over year
654
Homes sold in the period
+69 vs the year earlier
96%
Sold-to-list ratio
of asking price
80 days
Days to close
vs 75 days the year earlier
Source: ARMLS closed sales, all residential types, zip 85018, July 1, 2025 to July 29, 2026, compared with July 1, 2024 to July 29, 2025. A starting point, not a valuation for a specific home. Reviewed by Anne Sostman, The Brokery, Arizona License SA718853000, September 2026.

The Community

What defines Arcadia Proper.

North of Indian School Road

ArcadiaZip 85018Estate Tier

Go Deeper

Guides for Arcadia Proper.

Nearby

Other Arcadia communities.

Arcadia Proper

Common questions.

What do homes sell for in Arcadia Proper?

The median sale price in Arcadia Proper was $3.1M across 79 closed sales from July 2025 to July 2026, per ARMLS. That works out to a median of $819 per square foot. Homes took a median of 76 days on market and closed at 95% of list price. 21 homes are currently listed. Figures are a starting point for pricing, not a valuation of a specific property.

Where is Arcadia Proper?

Arcadia Proper is in Arcadia, Arizona, in zip code 85018. Arcadia Proper is the original Arcadia. Estate sized lots from half acre to 1+ acre, mature citrus trees, midcentury to contemporary architecture, and a $3.63M single family median (ARMLS, July 2025 to July 2026).

Is Arcadia Proper a guard gated community?

Arcadia Proper is not guard gated. Access is open, which widens the buyer pool and makes presentation and positioning matter more, since more of the market will see the home.

Who should I contact about selling a home in Arcadia Proper?

Anne Sostman of The Brokery represents sellers across Arcadia, including Arcadia Proper. She holds a marketing degree, began her career in worldwide marketing and creative advertising at Sony Pictures International, and directs the marketing strategy for every listing herself rather than applying a brokerage template. For a home in Arcadia Proper, that means a plan built for the specific buyer the property needs to reach.

Thinking of selling in Arcadia Proper?

A home here is not sold by listing it. It is sold by positioning it for the specific buyer who wants Arcadia, at the standard that buyer expects.